A few months back a grant came before Council with funds for the cities housing department. I made some strong statements stating that the City of Flagstaff should not be in the housing business. That grant was accepted by a vote of 6-1 so my thoughts were little could be done to get the City of Flagstaff out of the housing business.

Fast forward to the January 22 City Council Budget Discussion and I am hopeful that the City will be exiting this business. Many may not be aware that the City of Flagstaff has actually been building and selling spec homes as so called affordable housing. The affordable portion is supposed to be facilitated by the City owning the land that the house sits on. Someone buys the house and leases the land, commonly known as a ground lease. The theory is that the expensive part of the house is the land and by not selling the land you drive down the price of the house. A theory that may have made sense during the real estate bubble but clearly does not make sense in todays market or the foreseeable future.

And this is exactly what I pointed out Tuesday. While the Housing Department was presenting I pointed out that the City currently has two houses for sale at $169,900 and that there is an inventory of over 100 homes and town homes under $200,000 on the market right now. Why are we competing with a market with this kind of inventory? Why would someone want to buy a home with a tiny lot that they do not own when they have so many other choices with land they would own?

I’m pleased to report that the majority of Council agreed and once the current project near Coconino High School is complete, we will no longer be building spec houses and the city will be exiting this business.

As I’ve said before, we’ve got major financial issues to deal with. We need tens of millions just for our basic infrastructure needs. It’s time to change the way the City operates and the expectations of what the City provides. I’m proud to say progress is being made to streamline City operations and right the fiscal ship with much more work needed and much more to come.

3 thoughts on “NO MORE SPEC HOMES

  1. It’s about time some real common sense is being used in the decision making process at City Council meetings. Are we in the real estate investment business or are we supposed to be taking care of the city streets, utilities and safety issues first. The same applies to providing Charitable gifts and donations to private charities. This should be done privately by individuals who wish to be generous and support these groups. If we’re so far in the hole taking care of what the City is responsible for then why are we giving this money away to these purposes. If we generated excess money then it would be understandable. Why do we keep asking the voters and citizens of Flagstaff to keep approving Bond issues to cover shortages and at the same time give money away. Maybe it would be better to propose a Bond issue to raise money for Charitable donations and let the voters decide if that’s how they want to spend their tax dollars. As a private citizen I give to Charitable organizations because I feel I want to help but that’s purely my own choice.

  2. Jeff, I think this clearly demonstrates that when both the pros and cons of many issues facing the council are clearly explained the logic will prevail. Congrats!

  3. Jeff, I just want to thank you for being part of the council. Without you in it, I doubt the council would have decided to get out of the housing business. Keep up the good work.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s